California judge will order new trial in $289M Roundup award
California judge will order new trial in $289M Roundup award
Bottles of Roundup herbicide a product of Monsanto are displayed on a store shelf in St. Louis
13 October, 2018, 23:53
Two months ago, a jury awarded Johnson $39.2 million in compensatory damages and an additional $250 million in punitive damages after determining that Monsantoacted with "malice" and that its weed killers Roundup and the professional grade version RangerPro contributed "substantially" to Johnson's illness. Johnson is the first of more than 4,000 cancer patients to take Monsanto to trial.
Litzenburg said Johnson is still expecting to get $39 million in compensatory damages, though he "hasn't seen a dime" of that yet because that award is being appealed by Monsanto.
Lawyers for both sides are arguing in court Wednesday whether the improper arguments entitled Monsanto to a new trial.
Monsanto's attorney George Lombardi argued for a new trial, saying the comparing Monsanto to the tobacco industry was intentional and inaccurate. Johnson's attorney Michael Miller argued that the judge properly instructed the jury to disregard the comparison and to throw out their verdict because of the argument is too severe of a punishment.
The judge is deciding whether to toss out the jury's verdict order a new trial. (Jeff Roberson/AP File Photo)1:55 p.m.
A California judge is reportedly considering slashing the $289 million award to the cancer victim who repeatedly used Monsanto's weed-killer product Roundup while working as a school groundskeeper.
Superior Court Judge Suzanne Bolanos, who oversaw the trial, has the power to overturn the verdict, reduce the award amount or order a new trial.
Bolanos also said that the plaintiff hadn't offered enough proof that Monsanto's lack of detail on the potentially carcinogenic make up of its two products, was borne of malice or oppression, which is one of the requirements for securing punitive damages. However, Bolanos in her tentative noted that the plaintiff had failed to provide evidence that any Monsanto employee believed exposure to its glyphosate -based products would cause non-Hodgkin lymphoma. She said the evidence wasn't there to award $250 million in punitive damages. It isn't clear when the judge may finalize the ruling, issued ahead of a court hearing Wednesday. Attorneys for the company say Johnson failed to prove that Roundup or similar herbicides caused his lymphoma and presented no evidence that Monsanto executives were malicious in marketing Roundup.
"Mr. Johnson's story is tragic and could have been prevented if Monsanto actually showed a modicum of care about human safety", Johnson's lawyers also responded in court documents cited by the AP.
In terms of design, both phones employ a metal frame with glass fronts and backs - these are required to enable wireless charging. And Samsung started trolling the Pixel 3 and the ugly notch on the XL model as soon as Google unveiled it earlier this week.
Instead of the primary red and webbed design, most of the gloves are all black, with only the fingers having the webbed design. The argument could also be made that it adheres more closely to Spider-Man's appearance in Amazing Fantasy #15 back in 1962.
Town Manager David Lambert said he was prepared for Michael, but wasn't expecting much destruction. "It's hard to grasp", he said. Emergency personnel scoured through areas where entire blocks of homes and buildings were flattened, searching for survivors.
Team leader Kim was the first South Korean national to summit 14 peaks above 8,000 metres without using supplemental oxygen. Thapa, the police spokesman, said weather conditions on the mountain were preventing search-and-rescue efforts.
It was the first such incident in Russia's post-Soviet history - an unprecedented setback for the country's space industry. Kenny Todd, a space station manager, said from Houston that the space station crew can stay on board until January.
The bride is also wearing the Greville Emerald Kokoshnik Tiara, which was loaned to her by her grandmother, Queen Elizabeth II . The dress itself is a gorgeous shade of ivory with extra long sleeves covering the princess nearly to her fingertips.
Last night, gusts of wind were in excess of 110 km/h, with the western side of the country experiencing the strongest winds. Calmac cancelled many of its Western Isles ferries for the entire day and advised passengers to check before travelling.
German automaker BMW has increased its investment in the Chinese joint venture BMW Brilliance , The Paper reported. BMW also announced it plans to invest €3 Billion in the project, further expanding its production plants in China.
"Any load can not exceed 100 kilograms or one-fifth of the animal's body weight", the ministry's new rules stipulate. The activists claimed the animals were forced to endure long hours seven days a week with no rest, water or shelter.
As mentioned before, it was made clear that Danny Rand and his cohorts could return at some point in the future. Netflix and Marvel have announced that the series is ending after two seasons.
OPEC cuts oil demand estimate in 2019
Refinery crude runs fell by 352,000 barrels per day as utilisation rates dropped 1.6 percentage points, the EIA data showed. It may lower fuel demand in the USA southeastern markets by 1 million barrels a day, according to Mizuho Securities.
Actor Neha Pendse evicted from Bigg Boss 12?
While one set of contestants hurled accusations at others, the second set of contestants were to defend against the accusations. Dipika and Nehha tell KV that they should now start playing the game like how others are playing with them.
10 things to know about Aussies and mental health
According to experts, compared with adults, young people have less favourable attitudes towards people with mental illness. Schools will also be given help to measure their students' health, including their mental wellbeing, under the plans.
Pope Francis: Abortion Is 'Like Hiring a Hitman'
Pope Francis asks an attentive crowd. "Violence and the rejection of life are born from fear", the Pope added. Peter's Square, where he asked those gathered if it's ever OK to "take out a human life", Reuters reported .
Amazon abandons sexist AI-powered recruiting tool
The team, set up in Amazon's Edinburgh engineering hub, created 500 models concentrated on detailed job functions and locations. It would favor candidates that used language found on male candidate's resumes like "executed" and "captured".
Hawking's final work on 'black hole entropy' published
The eminent physicist Stephen Hawking , who past away previous year , was one of the world's foremost authorities on black holes . Now, the modern genius' final scientific paper has been completed and posted online by his colleagues for the world to revel in.
In A First, Healthy Mice Born From Same-sex Parents
This created embryos containing only genomic DNA from the two males, and these embryos were then transferred to surrogate mothers. They produced 29 live mice from 210 embryos, with the animals living to adulthood and having offspring of their own.
Six Palestinians killed in clashes on Israel border
A group of Palestinian terrorists set off a bomb on the Israel-Gaza Strip border on Friday and attacked a nearby IDF position. They also seek the right to return to lands that Palestinians fled or were driven from upon Israel's founding in 1948.
Federer, Djokovic advance to Shanghai semis
The 31-year-old Serb saved a set point against Anderson in an intense opener, before taking control in the tiebreak. Yet he made an aggressive start against Nishikori to take a 4-1 lead in the opening set.